CyberSaint Blog | Expert Thought

Cybersecurity Alert Overload is a CEO’s Problem; Here’s How to Fix It

Written by Jerry Layden | September 29, 2025

In today's digital landscape, organizations face an unprecedented volume of cybersecurity alerts on a daily basis. While these alerts are crucial for maintaining security, their sheer volume can overwhelm security teams, a phenomenon known as alert fatigue. This issue not only hampers the effectiveness of cybersecurity measures but also poses significant risks to business operations, financial performance, and organizational reputation. As CEOs and CFOs, understanding and addressing this challenge is imperative to safeguard your organization's assets and ensure sustained growth.​

The Escalating Challenge of Alert Fatigue

Security Operations Centers (SOCs) are inundated with alerts from various monitoring systems. A study by Cybereason revealed that 16% of SOC professionals manage only 50-59% of their alert pipeline each week, leaving a substantial portion unaddressed. This backlog can lead to missed critical threats and increased vulnerability to attacks.​

The consequences of alert fatigue extend beyond the security team. The Orca Security 2022 Cloud Security Alert Fatigue Report found that 62% of respondents experienced staff turnover due to alert fatigue, and 60% reported internal conflicts arising from the overwhelming number of alerts. This environment fosters a culture where critical threats may be overlooked, leading to potential security breaches.​

Real-World Implications for Business Operations

The repercussions of alert fatigue are not confined to the IT department; they permeate the entire organization. Consider the case of Stop & Shop, a grocery chain that experienced product shortages due to a cybersecurity incident affecting its supply chain and delivery operations. The disruption led to a scarcity of fresh produce, meat, and dairy products at stores in Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island, negatively impacting customer satisfaction and sales.

Similarly, Krispy Kreme faced a cyber-attack that disrupted its online ordering system for nearly two weeks. Approximately 16% of Krispy Kreme's sales come from online orders, and the disruption resulted in short-term financial losses due to reduced digital sales and increased cybersecurity expenses.

Financial Implications of Alert Fatigue

The financial ramifications of alert fatigue are profound. Expending resources to identify and mitigate cyberattacks inevitably leads organizations to see decreases in productivity. IT and security teams are forced to spend less time on business operations that can improve the user experience and give the company a competitive edge.​

Moreover, data breaches resulting from overlooked alerts can lead to significant financial losses. The average cost of a data breach in 2025 reached  $4.4 million, and the average time to identify and contain a breach was 241 days, according to the 2025 IBM Cost of a Data Breach Report. U.S.-based organizations fare even worse than the global average. The average cost of a data breach in the United States has reached a record high of $10.22 million. Compounding the detrimental effects of these breaches, organizations must also contend with legal penalties, regulatory fines, and a loss of customer trust, further impacting their bottom line.​

8 Strategies for CEOs and CFOs to Mitigate Alert Fatigue

As organizational leaders, CEOs and CFOs play a pivotal role in addressing alert fatigue. Here are key strategies to consider:

  1. Implement a Risk Management Framework: Adopt structured frameworks, such as the NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF), to guide risk management activities. These frameworks offer a systematic approach to identifying, assessing, and mitigating risks.​

  2. Leverage Advanced Technologies: Utilize AI-driven tools to analyze and correlate internal data (controls, assets, risks, gaps) with external threat intelligence. This approach helps filter out noise and focus on genuine threats.​

  3. Conduct Regular Risk Assessments: Perform continuous cyber risk assessments to identify vulnerabilities and adjust security measures accordingly. This proactive approach helps in staying ahead of potential threats and ditching the perpetual firefighting mode.

  4. Enhance Staff Training: Invest in regular cybersecurity training programs to ensure that staff can identify and respond to threats effectively. An informed team is a crucial defense against cyber threats.​

  5. Develop an Incident Response Plan: Establish a comprehensive incident response plan to ensure timely and effective action in the event of a security breach. Regularly update and test this plan to ensure it remains effective in adapting to evolving threats.​

  6. Optimize Security Tools: Consolidate and integrate security tools to reduce redundancy and improve efficiency. Ensuring that tools are correctly integrated can help reduce the overall number of alerts and false positives.​

  7. Prioritize Alerts: Implement risk-based alerting to focus on the most critical threats. This involves setting thresholds to prioritize alerts based on severity, ensuring that security teams can address the most pressing issues promptly.​ Findings management can overwhelm your security team without a prioritization method and contextualization. 
    1. Discover more about prioritized finding with our guide to cyber risk prioritization.

  8. Invest in Mental Health Support: Recognize the impact of alert fatigue on employee well-being and productivity. Implementing mental health support strategies can mitigate fatigue and improve employee well-being and organizational performance.​

Wrapping Up 

Alert fatigue is a pressing issue that extends beyond the IT department, impacting the entire organization's operational efficiency, financial performance, and reputation. As CEOs and CFOs, it is essential to acknowledge the seriousness of this challenge and take proactive steps to address it. By implementing robust risk management frameworks, leveraging advanced technologies, conducting regular risk assessments, enhancing staff training, developing comprehensive incident response plans, optimizing security tools, prioritizing alerts, and investing in mental health support, organizations can mitigate the risks associated with alert fatigue. 

These strategies not only bolster cybersecurity defenses but also ensure the organization's resilience in the face of evolving cyber threats.​